We will use data already collected from two completed randomized clinical trials for low back pain management in the Military Health System. For this study, we will use baseline data only.
Individuals seeking care for LBP in primary care (n=510) that participated in two previous trials.1,2
Preliminary Work and Background for Analysis Plan
To provide context for psychological status scores (that is, are scores high, low, or average among those with back pain?) and better understand the potentially unique distress characteristics and health care delivery needs of patients with low back pain undergoing conservative care, we will derive a comparison cohort from the Optimal Screening for Prediction of Referral and Outcome (OSPRO) development and validation cohort studies.3–5Descriptions of these cohorts were previously published5and include intake data from individuals (n = 871) seeking conservative care for a variety of knee, shoulder, low back, or neck pain conditions within the Orthopaedic Physical Therapy Investigator Network, a national network of outpatient physical therapy clinics. Briefly, the OSPRO development cohort (n = 431) was a cross-sectional cohort used to develop the OSPRO Yellow Flag (OSPRO-YF) Assessment tool, described in further detail below. The OSPRO validation cohort (n = 440) was subsequently and separately assembled as a longitudinal cohort to validate the newly-developed OSPRO-YF tool and establish its ability to predict clinical outcomes. Eligibility criteria for both the development and validation cohorts were identical and designed to make the cohort generalizable to outpatient orthopaedic rehabilitation populations. Because these two cohorts had identical eligibility criteria and both had baseline OSPRO-YF scores, we developed a combined sample that included baseline data from both cohorts as a comparison group for this study.
Description of Variables, Outcome Measures, and Data Sources
Demographic information (age, sex, race, ethnicity, education, employment status, marital status, tobacco use, service, rank, and benefit category) and patient-reported measures were collected at baseline. In the OSPRO cohort, baseline demographic variables, pain intensity, and psychological distress measures were available.
Patient Reported Measures
Baseline patient-reported measures include PROMIS Pain Interference, PROMIS Physical Function, PROMIS Sleep Disturbance, and PROMIS Anxiety and Depression
General and Pain-related Psychological Distress
The OSPRO-YF Assessment Tool is a multidimensional screening tool for general and pain-related psychological distress.5Using patient responses to each item, it accurately calculates estimates for what a patient would score on 11 full-length questionnaires measuring psychological constructs across three different domains. The three domains along with their associated psychological constructs (in parentheses) are: negative mood (depression, trait anxiety, trait anger), negative coping (fear-avoidance for work, fear-avoidance for physical activity, pain catastrophizing, kinesiophobia, and pain anxiety), and positive affect and coping (pain self-efficacy, self-efficacy for rehabilitation, and pain acceptance). The OSPRO-YF then uses those score estimates to identify the presence of a yellow flag for each of the 11 constructs. A yellow flag is a psychosocial prognostic factor for the development of disability after the onset of musculoskeletal pain. The presence of a yellow flag is based on meeting a score threshold for each of the full-length questionnaire score estimates. Score thresholds were established based on the sample distribution of full-length questionnaire scores in the previously described OSPRO development cohort.5Score estimates for negative mood and negative coping questionnaires within the top quartile of OSPRO development cohort scores indicate a yellow flag, whereas score estimates for positive affect and coping questionnaires that fall into the bottom quartile (suggesting higher psychological distress) indicate a yellow flag. For instance, if the quartile threshold for the Tampa Scale of Kinesiophobia (a negative coping questionnaire) is 30, then patients with a score estimate greater than 30 on the Tampa Scale of Kinesiophobia would have a yellow flag for kinesiophobia. This process results in 0 to 11 possible yellow flags. There are different versions of the tool, with the 10-item version representing the ideal combination of high accuracy and low response burden.6The 10-item OSPRO-YF version was collected in both trials. The OSPRO-YF has good internal validity, reliability, and predictive validity for persistent pain, disability, quality of life, and healthcare use. Using OSPRO-YF responses at the initial evaluation, we will calculate 11 full-length psychological questionnaire score estimates and the presence or absence of a yellow flag based on each of the 11 score estimates.